On Rizalito David’s disqualification case against Sen. Grace Poe

Comments

1. Mel says

   September 30, 2015 at 8:11 PM

   Latest on SET: Submission of Memorandums (October 6, 2015)

   Rizalito David’s camp bares discrepancies in Poe’s birth certificates

   By: Aries Joseph Hegina
   06:48 PM September 30th, 2015

   THE camp of Rizalito David, a defeated senatorial candidate in the 2013 polls who is seeking to unseat Senator Grace Poe, bared on Wednesday some discrepancies in her birth certificates which will supposedly bolster their claim that she is not a natural born Filipino.

   Showing the documents as part of the pieces of evidence they presented before the Senate Electoral Tribunal (SET), David’s counsel Atty. Manuelito Luna said that Poe’s birth certificate issued on November 27, 1968 showed specifically that she is a foundling.

   But in Poe’s other birth certificate, which was issued on May 4, 2006, it showed that she is a Filipino and the first-born in the family.

   Other “glaring” errors spotted by Luna on Poe’s 2006 birth certificate include:

   – declaring Jesusa Sonora Poe (Susan Roces) and Ronald Allan Kelley Poe (Fernando Poe Jr) as the biological parents of Poe

   – stating that Ronald Allan Kelley Poe is/was alive in 2006 as FPJ died on December 14, 2004

   – stating that Grace Poe is Jesusa Sonora Poe’s first-born child, and

   – the senator was born to the spouses Jesusa Sonora Poe and Ronald Allan Kelley Poe

   He said that if the Poes are acting in good faith, they should have put “NA” on her citizenship and “adopted” on the “birth order” in the items on her birth certificate.

   The lawyer claims that Poe secured the 2006 birth certificate in preparation of her reacquisition of her Philippine citizenship under the Dual Citizen Act, which she subsequently filed in July 2006. Since Poe is a foundling, she should not have been given the opportunity to reacquire her Filipino citizenship, Luna explained.

   Adoption invalid

   David’s camp also alleged that her adoption papers are invalid as these were granted by the municipal court in San Juan, Rizal.

   Luna said that adoption proceedings, as provided by law, could only be heard and granted in a regional trial court.

   David’s camp: We sympathize for Poe but…

   Luna said that while they recognize the status of Poe as a foundling, she still violated the Constitution by violating the requirements to run for a Senate seat as she is allegedly not a natural born Filipino.

   “We sympathize with her for being a foundling but we have to uphold the Constitution. We have to uphold the rule of law,” Luna told reporters.

   “Since she violated the requirements, unless she will be able to disprove our claim that she is not a natural born Filipino, then she is disqualified and ousted from the Senate,” he added.

   The said birth certificates, adoption paper, as well as travel documents and passport records of Poe and her children form part of the 140-page Offer of Evidence they filed before the Senate Electoral Tribunal (SET).

   The SET required both camps to submit their memorandum on the case on or before October 6, or 15 days after the September 21 oral arguments.

   Luna said that they will file their memorandum as early as October 1 or as late as October 5.

   Source: http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/726794/rizalito-davids-camp-bares-discrepancies-in-poes-birth-certificates

   Reply

2. Mel says

   September 11, 2015 at 5:06 PM

   Residency challenge vs Poe abandoned

   Ina Reformina, ABS-CBN News
   Posted at 09/11/2015 3:25 PM

   SET to focus on whether senator is a natural-born Filipino

   MANILA – For the first time since Rizalito David filed a quo warranto petition against the citizenship of Senator Grace Poe in August, both parties found themselves in the same room on Friday: the Supreme Court (SC) En Banc Conference Room for the preliminary conference scheduled by the Senate Electoral Tribunal (SET).

   The conference lasted for more or less 30 minutes, with both parties telling members of the media later that the main or threshold issue of the entire proceedings is whether or not Poe is a natural-born Filipino.

   Poe’s chief counsel, Atty. Alex Poblador, said the challenge to the lawmaker’s residency has been “abandoned.”

   Speaking to ABS-CBN News, David said the decision to set citizenship as the main issue was suggested by the SET through its chairman, Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio.

   Source: http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/09/11/15/residency-challenge-vs-poe-abandoned

   Reply

   • Mel says

     September 11, 2015 at 5:47 PM

     recent CPM comments

     https://raissarobles.com/2015/09/06/the-dark-side-of-jejomar-binay/comment-page-2/#comment-333663

     Reply

   • raissa says

     September 11, 2015 at 6:58 PM

     Mel,

     Sorry, I don’t know why your posts keep landing in moderation.

     Raissa

     Reply

     • Mel says

       September 11, 2015 at 7:04 PM

       I am always under attack. So it is with your other active commentators.

       Thanks mucho sa inyo. Ayos lang.

       All the best.

       Reply